FIRST ON FOX — A brand new examine is sounding the alarm on female-identifying, biologically male felons being incarcerated at female-only prisons, saying these inmates pose bodily and psychological dangers to organic girls.
The report from Impartial Girls, a nonprofit, launched Thursday and shared completely with Fox Information Digital, says “male inmates figuring out as girls are disproportionately more likely to have dedicated sexual offenses, and incarcerated girls face heightened dangers of harassment and assault beneath these insurance policies.
“Putting trans-identifying males, particularly these with totally intact male genitalia or a historical past of violent intercourse crimes, in shut quarters with feminine inmates dangers a critical deprivation of the feminine’s rights,” the report states. “These dangers — and the results which have already manifested for girls subjected to mixed-sex jail environments — are identified, however are being intentionally ignored in deference to legal guidelines and insurance policies that marginalize incarcerated girls and silence issues about their security.”
Amie Ichikawa spent 5 years in a California state jail after she was convicted of constructing terroristic threats with a gun. After her launch, she started advocating for feminine inmates involved about being housed with organic males.
BIOLOGICAL MEN ARE NOW WELCOME IN CALIFORNIA WOMEN’S PRISONS: ‘AN AGENDA FOR FEMALE ERASURE’
Amie Ichikawa spent 5 years in a California state jail after she was convicted of constructing terroristic threats with a gun. After her launch, she started advocating for feminine inmates involved about being housed with organic males. (Impartial Girls)
“It is as a result of the legal guidelines are based mostly on self-identification. The one requirement is for somebody to state that they’re a feminine,” Ichikawa informed Fox Information Digital. “You possibly can’t base your denials on bodily attributes, together with retention of a penis. You possibly can’t deny someone a switch based mostly on felony historical past.”
Male inmates who determine as feminine will usually sit earlier than a evaluate board to have instances heard and argue that sex-based prisons violate Equal Safety legal guidelines or declare they’re being discriminated in opposition to on the premise of intercourse.
Transgender, organic male inmates may also argue that their housing circumstances in male-only prisons violate the Eighth Modification’s prohibition in opposition to merciless and weird punishment, based on the Impartial Girls report.
ALMOST 75% OF TRANSGENDER PRISONERS BEHIND BARS FOR RAPE, BRUTAL CRIMES IN THE UK
In 4 states, organic male inmates who determine as feminine will be positioned in female-only prisons.
States that permit housing of trans-identifying inmates based mostly on gender identification. (Impartial Girls)
These states embrace California, Connecticut, Maine and New Jersey. Two states — Utah and Louisiana — prohibit males in girls’s prisons, whereas all others function on a case-by-case foundation.
As of October 2024, there have been 1,487 incarcerated males figuring out as girls in federal prisons — solely a few of whom are housed in feminine prisons, based on the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP).
Folks wave a Transgender Pleasure flag on the 2023 LA Pleasure Parade June 11, 2023, in Hollywood, Calif. (Robyn Beck/AFP through Getty Photographs)
Almost half of trans-identifying male prisoners have intercourse convictions, in comparison with lower than 12% of the final male jail inhabitants nationwide, based on BOP statistics cited within the Impartial Girls report.
“Girls don’t should be housed in locked prisons with violent felony males, interval,” mentioned Could Mailman, authorized director at Impartial Girls. “In the course of the [2024 presidential] marketing campaign, Kamala Harris, unashamed of her overt backing of trans-identifying males in girls’s prisons, tried to point the regulation required such madness.Â
“She was unsuitable. ‘Merciless and Uncommon Punishment: Stopping the Harmful Insurance policies Placing Males in Girls’s Prisons’ makes clear that coverage leaders maintain clear authority to guard girls and implement sanity. This can be a must-read for politicians and their workers attempting to finish the predations of gender ideology.”
Transgender coverage advocates say housing female-identifying inmates in female-only prisons permits them to dwell in a safer surroundings as a result of transgender girls face sexual abuse in male-only prisons.
“Prisons and jails routinely topic transgender individuals of their care to abusive circumstances, together with denial of medical care, prolonged durations of solitary confinement, and harassment, sexual assault, and violence by the hands of guards and different individuals with whom they’re incarcerated,” the Transgender Legislation Heart states on its web site. “Current research present that transgender girls are 13 instances extra more likely to be sexually assaulted in jail than others.”
However feminine inmates have additionally confronted sexual abuse by the hands of transgender inmates who’re biologically male, and so they really feel their issues are usually not being addressed.
Feminine inmate Dana Grey informed Impartial Girls she was sexually assaulted by a transgender girl “that was bodily intact” in January 2023.
Feminine inmate Dana Grey informed Impartial Girls she was sexually assaulted by a transgender girl “that was bodily intact” in January 2023. (Impartial Girls)
“It was terrifying and disgusting as a result of I knew there was nothing I might do,” Grey mentioned.
“This can be a excellent Computer virus into the largest sufferer pool anybody might ever hope and dream of.”
“The trans neighborhood has been hijacked as a hiding place for very mentally unwell intercourse criminals,” Ichikawa mentioned. “This can be a excellent Computer virus into the largest sufferer pool anybody might ever hope and dream of. There [are] trans girls that I converse to in males’s prisons that need nothing to do with this and are horrified on the folks that the states and federal establishments are permitting to switch over [to female prisons].”
Additional, these in opposition to housing transgender inmates in female-only prisons additionally set off traumatic occasions for some girls.
Youngster intercourse trafficking survivor Alissa Kamholz needed to share a cell with a female-identifying man affiliated with the identical gang as her childhood abusers, based on the report.
Youngster intercourse trafficking survivor Alissa Kamholz needed to share a cell with a female-identifying man affiliated with the identical gang as her childhood abusers, based on the report. (Alissa Kamholz)
Ichikawa believes there are some males who determine as feminine to rig the system and be despatched to a girls’s jail to have extra energy than they’d in a males’s jail.
The subject of housing transgender inmates in female-only prisons has prompted lawsuits and jarring information headlines throughout the nation.
Final yr, a person posing as a transgender feminine inmate at Riker’s Island raped a feminine inmate, based on a lawsuit filed by the sufferer. Additionally, final yr, Tremaine Deon Carroll, a organic male California inmate who identifies as feminine was charged with two counts of forcible rape and considered one of “dissuading a witness from testifying” after allegedly attacking a lady at Central California Girls’s Facility, based on a felony criticism first obtained by the web site 4W and later reported by Reduxx.
Tremaine “Tremayne” Deon Carroll, 52, a violent offender incarcerated in California, was charged with rape in Madera County. A transgender particular person, Carroll was housed in a girls’s jail by request and transferred to a males’s jail after an indictment for rape. (CDCR)
Demi Minor, a New Jersey transgender inmate, impregnated two feminine inmates in 2022. Moore later expressed worry after being transferred out of the female-only jail in an interview with NJ.com. An Indiana decide dominated final yr {that a} female-identifying, organic male convicted of killing a child might get state-funded transgender surgical procedure.Â
Hannah Tubbs is a transgender California inmate who, at 17 years previous, was convicted of molesting a younger woman in a Denny’s toilet in 2017. Underneath former District Legal professional George Gascon’s mandates for suspects beneath 18, Tubbs, who was 26 when the case was ultimately tried, acquired a softball sentence of two years in a juvenile facility for women as a result of the date of the offense was simply days earlier than Tubbs’ 18th birthday.
Hannah Tubbs started figuring out as feminine after being arrested in a 2014 youngster molestation case in Los Angeles County. (Los Angeles County)
Earlier than he might full the sentence, nonetheless, a 27-year-old Tubbs was charged in Kern County with first-degree homicide, threatening a witness, theft and assault. Tubbs pleaded responsible to manslaughter and lesser prices in change for a 15-year jail sentence in November 2023.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
IWF’s new documentary sequence, “Merciless & Uncommon Punishment: The Male Takeover of Feminine Prisons,” shares tales of abuse and retaliation for voicing their issues concerning the subject.
The IWF report is asking for options, together with amending the Jail Rape Elimination Act to “stop gender identity-based transfers to girls’s prisons,” clarifying that the People with Disabilities Act “doesn’t mandate ‘transition’ providers or mixed-sex housing,” defending feminine inmates’ rights to report abuse with out retaliation, “eliminating reliance on activist medical tips” and “tying federal jail funding to insurance policies that prioritize security for feminine inmates.”
